Monday, February 28, 2011

Two into one can't go

Once again, Flora Hill ward ratepayers have been dudded. How can a funeral home and park exist in the same space? According to the Council, quite easily.

In 2008, the masterplan for the redevelopment of Wolstencroft St Park was revealed. Funds were allocated at that point from the budget for the first stage, but when the new council was elected in November 2008, the masterplan slipped off the agenda and off the website. Here is a link to the plan
Wolstencroft Masterplan.


It is only after lobbying from the Wolstencroft Area Action Group (WAAG ) that the masterplan was reinstated and a vague commitment at Christmas time  from a director (who has subsequently resigned from council) to include the works for stage 1 into this years’ budget considerations.

It was about this time that murmurings about a funeral home going into the area surfaced.(Check this facebook page Opponents-to-the-Flora-Hill-Miller-Street-Funeral-Parlour-Proposal). This has now turned into a fact with council looking to approve an application on Wednesday.

The analysis of the application by council officers is flawed. It does not take into account the concerns of the 90+ petitions against the proposal (scoffing at the proforma nature of the petitions, not the substance), rejects any mediation process (because the large number of people who have raised concerns will make it difficult) and does not fully appreciate the traffic and parking nightmares this application will create (Miller St is only one lane each way, Havlin St East smaller than that)

The approval conditions imposed on the applicant are laughable and cannot be policed.  Who is going to tell a mourning family that you can only have 100 people attend the funeral, no more are allowed? Who is going to count the number of funerals and dob when the count reaches more than a 100 for the year?

The application notes that the Wolstencroft development and this application are mutually exclusive. They are not; they will affect the fabric of the community in different ways and would be inextricably entwined. One will be celebration of life, the other a reminder of death. Try explaining that contradiction to the kids while you’re chucking the Frisbee around, or explaining why the nice man/lady has collapsed with grief in front of you as hand your child another sausage from the BBQ.

Flora Hill ward doesn’t ask for much – it is an established area with established infrastructure. We pay our rates and most of it goes to the CBD. What we do ask is some consideration of our needs and concerns, especially for something a confronting as a funeral home.

Build the park.

Don’t build the funeral home.    

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

New direction?

Every year I sit down at the end of the year, evaluate what goals I have achieved, beat myself up for the stuff I haven’t accomplished and then set goals for the coming year.


This year I have decided to do something a bit different.
I have stumbled across this site, which made a lot of sense to me- it also gave me a bit of an ‘aha’ moment which is always a good sign
http://zenhabits.net/simple-living-manifesto-72-ideas-to-simplify-your-life

I’m going to try to implement as many of these ideas over the course of the year – if I remember I will try to blog about my success (or otherwise!)

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Phillip John Toman

Today is the anniversary of my brothers death - he has now been dead for 19 years. Next year it will be 20 years dead which is a counter balance to his 20 years of life. The year after that he will have been dead longer than he was alive.


It deeply saddens me that my wife and children have never met this man who has paid an integral part in my development as person. My eldest son, who has his Uncles' name for a middle name - seems to be exhibiting some of Phillips' personality traits, which is very pleasing.

I've recently been doing family history stuff - I blame my mother for this -and have tracked strands of my ancestors back to the 1500s. As I'm researching and completing the family tree, it strikes me that I know nothing about these people except their name (John Toman), their approximate birthdate (born about 1750) who they married (Jane Lavis m14 Feb 1778) their children (John born about 1778, Jane about 1780, Samuel about 1782) and their death (12 July 1839). For a stretch of about 100 years, all my direct male ancestors were named John Toman, but I have no idea what they were called on a daily basis. Was John, Johnny, Jack, Little John, JT or Sam? Some of these people lived 80+ years, but all I have is a bunch of dates, no other record of their life.

My brother, the middle child, is Phillip John Toman. He was born 15 December 1970, and was killed whilst crossing a wet dark Melbourne road at about 6.30pm on Sunday the 15 September 1991.

For me, at the grand old age of 21 and some months, it was my first real experience of death. Since then of course death has come to me in various guises- suicide by car, cancer, old age and unfortunate circumstance. Victims have included favorite Aunts, Nan, work mates, the guy going out with your girlfriends best mate and guys you had a nodding relationship with. However, as my first real taste of death, Phillips' was a excruciatingly painful one.

For 18 or so years, we shared a room and I like to believe we were close-certainly in the last 18 months or so of his life we became closer. I don't have any great stories to tell you or some great insights into the meaning behind his death - the stories are kept alive in my memory for my own private reflection. I simply could not do justice to any story by writing it down.
In June 1991, Phillip, his girlfriend and I went for a holiday in Surfers - the first time I had flown or been to Surfers. I'm pretty sure it was the same for Phillip. We stayed at his girlfriends parents holiday apartment, a block from the beach on about the 15th floor. We stayed for 10 days, maybe 2 weeks. Phillip managed to set foot on the beach the night before we left Surfers Paradise - in some ways that typified him.

As a brother, he was hopeless with outdoor games - couldn't kick a football, wasn't interested in cricket. He was always more interested in reading, or playing board games or listening to music.

On Friday the 13th of September 1991, I was at work and thought that I should call Phillip, it had been a week or so since we had spoken the Bank could pay for the STD charges - Nah, I'll do it Monday I better serve that customer - Next please!
On Sundaythe 15th, Phillip and some mates went to the Daimaru Shopping Center that had just opened. I know they were there for some time and really enjoyed it. They all went back to his mates flat at the corner of Dandenong Rd and Williams Rd. Phillip went to the nearby shop to get something- I'm not sure what but probably the crappy clove cigarettes he was smoking at the time.

As nights go, this was pretty cold and wet. It was also the really dark dark you get when the weather is terrible, the sun has just gone down and your headlights really aren't having much effect. Phillip had some new shoes on, with little to no grip and dressed all in black. The little red man on the traffic light was red- not flashing red, solid red. Phillip pushed past the waiting pedestrian onto the wet road.

The driver of the car was a teacher, who had had a few over the course of the afternoon - I don't know his name and have never had cause to find out. Thankfully for him he was under 0.05 - I always felt he didn't need the extra guilt. The green arrow came on and he turned right into Williams Rd, crossing over the tram lines and other 3 lanes of traffic
The spot where Phillip was hit is innocuous enough in the daylight, and it is hard to believe that anything could possibly occur at that spot. He slipped, and was on one knee when the car hit him. He was dragged 20 meters down the road, and the car had to be lifted off him. The best guess is that he died instantly, though I have never seen a coroners report - I certainly hope he felt no fear or pain in his final seconds.
In some respects Phillip's death was the best thing to happen to me.

It took me some time to move my way through the some times paralysing grief. It wasn't helped that I was in the middle of a relationship break-up and all my support was 120ks away. Once I had managed to survive one day, it became easier to survive other days. Gradually over time, I was able to string good days together. His death led me to Buddhism and views on death.

Phillip was not a saint, had no real answers about life or special way about him. He was taller than me- close to 6ft, but ran like a girl and smoked his cigarettes in a really weird way. He hated being called Flip, tolerated Phil, preferred Phillip. He barracked for Collingwood when he was younger, but outgrew that. He was always the Elven Thief in Dungeons and Dragons games and liked to listen to Kylie Minouge and the Cure. He worked in a library and lasted one semester at Monash. He took pride in his hair and once helped me push a stubborn floater down his toilet.

As the circle of people who knew Phillip start to diminish, it saddens me that he will be a footnote in a future genealogists family tree. This is my attempt to use up some kilobytes in the hope that someone sometime will read this and have a sense of who he was.

His name was Phiilip John Toman, born 15/12/1970, died 15/9/1991.

His family still miss him everyday.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Hang down your head (Tom Dooley)

Well, hasn't 33 days of electioneering and 17 days of pondering just flown. I was disappointed in the Federal result overall, but locally the campaign was a great result - a combination of hard work by the campaign team and the overall weakness of the competing candidates campaign.

I sincerely hope that that Julia can make this hung parliament work. There is a great opportunity here to really engage the voting public, get them involved and care about what an engaged and vigorous government can do. In 10 years time, I feverently hope that we can look back and say ' This was the making of her as a great PM".

Time will tell.

Friday, July 16, 2010

Election fever fever

So, by 11am tomorrow (17 July), we will have a Federal election date. I'm pretty excited, because it is the first Federal or State election campaign that I will (hopefully) have an active but small part in as an Executive member of the Bendigo FEA.

I'm looking forward to observing how a professional campaign is run, and how it contrasts it with my Council efforts.

Will Julia win? Gut feel is, of course she will, with an increased majority. TAbbott has been keeping a low profile lately, but that option will not be available when the election is called. Abbott will self-combust at some stage (remember what happened at last election when he was just the Health Minister), the trick is whether the media will report his gaffes as breathlessly/stridently as the Labor errors.

I'm hoping for something inspirational, something to grab the attention something that will make people actually care. Julia nearly had it with her Asylum seeker speech at the Lowy Institute, but fell short. My fear is that it will be another long slog - 33 days of meaningless rhetoric, dodgy pressers and endless carping about semantics. And then, when Election day finally rolls around, the voters approach it with a feeling of relief that it is finally over, rather than one of hope and expectation.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

The battle of who could care less

One of my recent hobbies has been becoming more interested and involved in the goings on of my local council – The City of Greater Bendigo. I even put my hand up as a candidate at one stage, which was an amazing insight into my own frailties and fears.

There is currently a by-election occurring in the North West Plains ward, which is the largest (in geographically area) ward in the city. There is a representation review due to occur within the next 18 months, so this ward composition will most likely be changed at the next general election anyway so this only a 2 year term.


It may prove to be an overdose of democracy for some with a local, state and federal election occurring within a few months of each other – a battle to engage apathetic voters.

This election is also likely to be swallowed up in the Federal campaign and be deprived of the oxygen it deserves, which is a shame because this ward contains three of the major growth areas targeted by the council in its Bendigo Residential Development Strategy: Marong, Maiden Gully and Huntly.

The ward was capably served by Kevin Gibbins until his untimely death in April. Whoever is elected will have an enormous job to try and emulate the success and energy Kevin displayed in his time on council.

There are three major challenges within the ward that have not been addressed (as far as I can see) by the 7 candidates in their campaign literature and media releases.

1) The proposed Marong industrial park and compulsory acquisition of the Carter farm property.

2) Relocation of the landfill (preferred option in August 2008 was at Clays Road, Bagshot. The previous preferred option was in Millwood Road Huntly).

3) What are their thoughts on the proposed push to make Marong and Huntly preferred residential destinations?

I don’t know any of the candidates and I don’t live in the ward so my commentary is a bit limited on what they are actually campaigning on. For what it is worth, here is my attempt at an analysis.

Bruce Phillips – Number one on the ballot, with good preference deals locked in with Elaine Harrington and Wendy Radford. Has also reportedly called ‘shenanigans’ on an unrequited preference deal with Stuart Symes as well as questioning some dodgy posters. The downside with Phillips is he has previously been a councillor so the ‘new blood’ meme is not possible. In an election that may not register too highly with the residents, he may get a lot of donkey votes.

Karel Zegers – has tried a couple of times to be elected to this position, but has fallen short. Good position on the ballot paper but the lack of a good preference deal may hurt. He has also suggested that his preference deal with Symes was not reciprocated and he has even gone to the expense of showing the changed preferences in his ads.

Elaine Harrington – without a doubt, Elaine is taking this fairly seriously. She has to because she has a lot of baggage to overcome after losing her position as Eaglehawk councillor in November 2008. Her campaign seems a touch more polished than the others – the custom email address is a nice touch. A reasonable position on the ballot paper, with good preference deals with Phillips and Wendy Radford.

Stephen Robinson – poor ballot draw. His preferences are, remarkably, fundamentally the same as Ian Beath and Stuart Symes

Wendy Radford – She has previously run in the November 2008 elections. Poor ballot position with no decent preference deals locked away. She is the only candidate to publically proclaim their membership of a political party.

Stuart Symes – The founder (and some would say the only member) of the Bendigo Action Group has locked in some great preference deals (he is number 2 for three candidates and number 3 for another), despite the calls of ‘shenanigans’. The challenge will be whether those who care at all about this election will take into account the reports of broken deals and punish accordingly.

Ian Beath – Great ballot position to take advantage of the ‘reverse donkey’. Like Robinson, his preference deals are remarkable in their similarity with Symes.


So, what does this mean? (Bearing in mind I don’t have all the candidate information in front of me and I haven’t heard any reports of how they performed at the open forum in Marong on June 25th)

I think I would like either Zegers or Harrington to win, simply because of the previous attempts (Zegers) and efforts (Harrington) being displayed.

Gut feel, I think that Bruce Phillips is in the driving seat of this one. He has the position and the preference flows to win it, with Stuart Symes being the runner up.*

The final results would be something like this:-

1) Bruce Phillips

2) Stuart Symes

3) Karel Zegers

4) Elaine Harrington

5) Ian Beath

6) Wendy Radford

7) Stephen Robinson


* I do reserve the right to change this prediction.

The art of non grasping

As a Buddhist, I need to embrace and practice the concept of ‘non-grasping’. That is, do not become irrationally attached to people and things because every thing is impermanent and subject to change.

As a male, I need to embrace and practice with the new iPhone 4. Actually, more than a need, it is an absolute craving. A hole in my soul that needs to be plugged by iPhone-y awesomeness.

I will be off my current phone contract in 40 days, I have never had an iPhone, not sure why I desperately want one now but gimme gimme gimme!

I not sure how I can reconcile these two differing views, but I promise you I will find a way.